Skip to main content
The Kitchen Archive

Eats Archive › Pizza

Pizza

Best pizza in the Burgh?

10 posts · Jan 12, 1995 to Jan 17, 1995

AnonymousCarnegie Mellon, Pittsburgh, PAJan 12, 1995
Someone wrote:
> Does anybody have any suggestions about the best pizza in Pittsburgh?  I
> live in the East (Churchill), so any comments about places in the city or
> out around in the Monroeville area would be appreciated!

I don't know about east of the city but the best pizza I've found in the area is south: Caruso's, in Mt. Lebanon. Great pizza (both traditional and white) and a friendly staff.

****************************************************************** Jim Mann				[email removed] Transarc Corporation The Gulf Tower, 707 Grant Street, Pittsburgh, PA 15219  (412) 338-4442
WWW Homepage:
  file://grand.central.org/afs/transarc.com/public/jmann/html/Home.html
AnonymousTelerama Public Access Internet, Pittsburgh, PAJan 12, 1995
 Someone wrote:
 > Does anybody have any suggestions about the best pizza in Pittsburgh?  I
 > live in the East (Churchill), so any comments about places in the city or
 > out around in the Monroeville area would be appreciated!

 You will either love it or hate it, but you must give Vincent's Pizza on
 Ardmore Blvd. right outside of Forest Hills a try.
James S.Carnegie Mellon, Pittsburgh, PAJan 13, 1995
 Talk about subjects which have been beaten to death. Well my favorite
 places are Mineos on Murray Ave in Squirrel Hill and Pino's on Reynolds
 in Point Breeze. Both are quite good but I guess the locations don't
 suit you.
 --------------------------------esp------------------------------------------
 James Stepanek               NRA member                    Graduate Student
 Materials Science and Engineering                Carnegie Mellon University
 God created mankind, Samuel Colt made them equal.
 Thank God I'm an atheist.
 These opinions are mine alone, others can find their own.
 -------------------------Don't tread on me-----------------------------------
Bill T.Graduate School of Industrial Administr., Carnegie Mellon, Pittsburgh, PAJan 13, 1995
 Excerpts from netnews.pgh.food: 12-Jan-95 Re: Best pizza in the Burgh?
 by [email removed]
 > I don't know about east of the city but the best pizza I've found in
 > the area is south: Caruso's, in Mt. Lebanon. Great pizza (both
 > traditional and white) and a friendly staff.
 >

 We've been getting Caruso's pizza since Jim Mann last recommended it. It
 is excellent. Bado's on Beverly Road, Mt. Lebanon, is also outstanding.
 Only problem with Caruso's is figuring out where to put your car while
 you pick up the pizza.
Mary J.Biological Sciences, Carnegie Mellon, Pittsburgh, PAJan 13, 1995
 Another chance to plug my neighborhood favorite: Rialto's in Greenfield.
  I don't know about it being the "best" in Pittsburgh, but it does have
 good pizza, good subs, good prices, good service.  We eat there more
 often than I really care to admit!  Part of that is because their phone
 number is so easy to remember: 421-2121.  If we're out running errands,
 we can call from a pay phone and pick up our order on the way home.  I
 think I'll stop now before this becomes any more pathetic!

 Mary
Peter B.Telerama Public Access Internet, Pittsburgh, PA USAJan 13, 1995
 The restaurant downstairs from us, Portobello, has great pizza.  Excellent
 crispy crust, not fluffy and soft like most I've had.  Unfortunately, he
 only delivers to So. Side/Mt. Lebanon, not Squirrel Hill.
George P.University of PittsburghJan 13, 1995
 Laura and others:

 Vincent's Pizza Palace down on Ardmore Blvd. in Forest Hills is the best
 that I have discovered so far.  Like you, I live in Churchill - but only
 for a few months.  Vincent's uses huge chunks of sausage and pepperoni,
 which being a true carnivore, I approve of.  The atmosphere is
 entertaining, and returning to Churchill afterwards is a bitch - you can
 only go exit south on Ardmore and have to go a least a mile before you
 can turn around - but worth it.

 Also, I've enjoyed Mineo's on Murray in Squirrel Hill and have gotten
 good recommendations to Minutello's in Shadyside from this group.

 George Pike
 In article , Laura111
 wrote: >Does anybody have any suggestions about the best pizza in
 Pittsburgh?  I >live in the East (Churchill), so any comments about places
 in the city or >out around in the Monroeville area would be appreciated!
Bill C.School of Computer Science, Carnegie Mellon UniversityJan 13, 1995
    You will either love it or hate it, but you must give Vincent's Pizza on
    Ardmore Blvd. right outside of Forest Hills a try.

 I'm glad you are enthusiastic.  I never loved or hated Vincent's in the past
 14 years.  I mostly stopped eating there a long time ago because you never
 know when the loser will be open.  He used to close all the time for long
 periods of time.  Now I'd never eat there because of the health hazards.
 Never once 10s of pizzas did I see him serve sausage that was not raw in the
 middle.  People joke about it, but you are definitely eating cigarette ashes
 at times.  The counter where he works is unsanitary.

 Sure, go there to see a PGH institution.  I know one or even several visits
 probably won't kill you.  It isn't really worth the effort to bother though.
 If you do go there, you have to sit in the back dining room; it has netting
 all over the ceiling with fake grape vines that looked like they raked the
 yard and threw the leaves up there, but the truly great thing is the little
 Christmas lights laced through the grape vines.  Of course, if you sit in
 the front room, multiple velvet paintings with STRONG religious themes will
 be your treat.

 Bill
Dreamer D.Telerama Public Access Internet, Pittsburgh, PAJan 15, 1995
 Someone wrote:
 > Does anybody have any suggestions about the best pizza in Pittsburgh?  I
 > live in the East (Churchill), so any comments about places in the city or
 > out around in the Monroeville area would be appreciated!
 I am a pizza addict so I have searched the city and suburbs for the best
 pizza.
 I live close to vincents, I wouldn't reccommend it personally.
 the best pizza in my opinion in da burgh is Fiori's pizzaria on the
 corner of capital ave and west liberty ave in beechview.
 they also opened a second shop in south park.
 They are open until 3am too, so if ya get the late night jonez for
 pepperoni you can go there.
 good luck and happy eating!
 Darla
Pedro B.University of PittsburghJan 17, 1995
 Hi:

 I have tasted some nice pizzas at a place on Carson St. called
 Bella Pizza. They sell by the slice and that way if you don't
 like it you won't have to pay for the whole pie. Just my $0.0001.
Share this page