Skip to main content
The Kitchen Archive

Eats Archive › Pennsylvania › Pittsburgh

Pittsburgh, PA

Looking for real Mexican in Pittsburgh

5 posts · Aug 13, 1998 to Aug 21, 1998

AnonymousDeja News - The Leader in Internet DiscussionAug 13, 1998
 I am seeking REAL Mexican food or S. Cal Mexican in Pittsburgh.

 - REAL means down home, authentic...al pastor, ceviche, shrimp (or shrimp &
 octopus) soup, lard-laden refritos...etc, and may include "dive" atmosphere
 and even mariachi.

 - S. Cal means fish tacos, real fresh salsa, maybe some light, inventive
 combinations.

 All require good margaritas.  I've travelled Pittsburgh over, and none
 qualify...

 >Mad Mex - poor S. Cal attempt, not even close to real.  I think they use

 "squeeze cheese" on certain things, margaritas are overpriced and generally
 not very good.

 >Cozumel - maybe closer to real, but more americanized real, with little true
 variety on their menu

 >Fajita Grill - not really worth mentioning.  Foo foo gourmet attempt
 mexican...dry (both in Marg. and moisture content of the pseudo-tamales I once
 ordered), qualifies as neither of the sought after styles

 >Don Pablos - actually (scarily) one of the better, though too american-Chi Chi
 'ized, no good variety

 >some place tucked in the wilds of the north hills I can't remember - pretty
 good, yet standard American mex menu

 I've done many others (Jose and Tony's -ick, Pollo Rey, some strip mall in
 Monroeville, etc, etc).

 Any help/suggestions in Pittsburgh?

 What's good?
 I'm from Milwaukee with a large hispanic population and good
 restaurants...Conejito's, Rudy's, Tres Hermanos

 My girlfriend is from San Diego...Rubio's, Wanna Iguana...and there's a ton of
 REAL there too.
Jim M.Slurp News FeedsAug 14, 1998
 Sorry man,
 The best Mexican I know of is in Cleveland (Luchita's on 117th)
 I'm ashamed to admit we frequent Don Pablo's for margaritas, but they're the
 best in Pittsburgh, AFAIK.  Really pricey, though.  Bring your Visa card.
 Eats-wise - I'm with you...way too Chi-Chi, but far more tolerable.  Their
 service
 is more than a little unorganized.

 El Campensino is not bad for a family-run Mexican place, but aen exremely
 typical
 menu.  A bit low budget, food-wise - BYOB.

 wrote in message ...
 >I am seeking REAL Mexican food or S. Cal Mexican in Pittsburgh.
 >
 >- REAL means down home, authentic...al pastor, ceviche, shrimp (or shrimp &
 >octopus) soup, lard-laden refritos...etc, and may include "dive" atmosphere
 >and even mariachi.
 .
 .
 .
 >My girlfriend is from San Diego...Rubio's, Wanna Iguana...and there's a ton
 of
 >REAL there too.
 >
John A.Aug 14, 1998
NNTP-Posting-Date: Fri, 14 Aug 1998 18:25:33 EDT
Organization: Stargate Industries, LLC.
Xref:  pgh.food:7966

Someone wrote:

>I am seeking REAL Mexican food or S. Cal Mexican in Pittsburgh.

>>Don Pablos - actually (scarily) one of the better, though too american-Chi Chi
>'ized, no good variety

As one who spent 11+ years in South Texas, Don Pablo's comes closest to what we had there. Not perfect, but pretty damn close. I never cared for the California tendency to put Sour Cream and Guacamole on everything. I like mine a bit spicy.

I think that DP is is LIGHT YEARS above Chi-Chi's. They may have the same cookie-cutter atmosphere, but the food is much much better and closer to authentic.

If you ever get to Charlotte, NC in your travels, go to AZTECA on Woodlawn Blvd just east of I-77. They have about 30 native Mexicans running that place and it is great!!! Most from Matamoros, Guadelajara and Monterrey. Family place and they know what they are doing!

John
Kate C.University of PittsburghAug 18, 1998
 wrote in article ...
 >   Someone wrote:
 > > >Fajita Grill - not really worth mentioning.  Foo foo gourmet attempt
 > > mexican...dry (both in Marg. and moisture content of the pseudo-tamales
 I once
 > > ordered), qualifies as neither of the sought after styles
 >
 > IMO Fajita Grill is the best mexican you'll find in Pittsburgh...

 It used to be.  It used to be some of the best Mexican I've had anywhere
 including
 most of the southwestern states.  But that was in the Pleasant Hills days.
 I finally
 got to their new Shadyside location recently and was appalled at the
 changes -
 all for the worse as far as I am concerned.   I agree with the original
 poster.
 Ptui!

 > one you didn't mention that's worth checking out is Mago Latino
 > on Liberty Ave. in Bloomfield.  Some of their stuff is quite
 > good, but it's BYOB like Fajita Grill so it doesn't really fit
 > your qualifications.

 A big disappointment after reading posts raving about it after it first
 opened.

 And we went to Casa Chapala last weekend.  I had been there once before
 when it was in Somerset.  I thought it was pretty good then, but I was
 somewhat
 disappointed this time.  Not by lack of authenticity, but by poor quality.
 I had
 the tacos al carbon which would have been great except for the large amount
 of
 gristle in the meat.  Also the sauce on the tamal sucked and the rice and
 beans
 lacked flavor.  I did like the queso fundido and the nachos we had as
 appetizers.

 Kate
AnonymousAug 21, 1998
 >>  >some place tucked in the wilds of the north hills I can't remember -
 >pretty
 >> > good, yet standard American mex menu
 >> >
 >> probably Franklin Inn
 >
 >Does anyone with Latino experience have a good rundown on the Franklin Inn?
 >I've
 >heard about it many times, and don't know where it is.  I'm interested in
 >trying it
 >if it's above average.
 >

 Hi, I live and work in the *wilds of the North Hills*.  Franklin Inn does have
 decent Mexican food. My favorite time to go is on a weekend. They have some
 good egg dishes and chorizo ones as well. Their menu is not real extensive, but
 they do have great food IMHO.  I have not been impressed with other Mexican
 restaurants here in Pittsburgh, but when I want Mexican, I'll go to the
 Franklin.

 The easiest way to get there:  get off the Camp Horne exit of 279 and head east
 until you get to Mt. Nebo Road. Take it until it passes back under 279 and turn
 right onto McAleer Rd.  Take that to the end of the road and turn right (that's
 Rochester Rd.).  In about a mile, maybe less, the Franklin Inn will be on your
 right.

 Blessings, Priscilla
Share this page