Skip to main content
The Kitchen Archive

Eats Archive › Pennsylvania › Pittsburgh

Pittsburgh, PA

Best Pizza in Pittsburgh

22 posts · Feb 3, 1996 to Feb 15, 1996

Eric S.Senior, English, Carnegie Mellon, Pittsburgh, PAFeb 3, 1996
 The best place I've been to in the city is Mineo's, on Murray Avenue in
 Squirrel Hill. Take the Squirrel Hill exit off the Parkway (exit 8). The
 pizza is excellent, there's other kinds of food, and the price is really
 good.

 The best place I've been to outside the city is in Mt. Lebanon, and I
 was only there once, and it was a long time ago. I think it was called
 Beto's, but it might be Bedo's, or something like that. The pizza was
 good, and there was a good selection of other food, too - again not too
 expensive. I was with my gf when I went, and she knows the directions,
 but I don't. I can remember going through the Fort Pitt Tunnel off the
 Parkway and taking one of the first exits (something Road?) and
 following that road. Sorry I can't remember more.. Maybe someone else
 can help?

 Good luck.

 ERIC
Edward P.Dimensional CommunicationsFeb 3, 1996
 i HONESTLY DON'T REMEMber the name of one place but it is in the Penn
 Hills Shopping Center off of Frankstown Rd. about 3 stores down from Hills.

 The Best Pizza I had was at Artie's in Trafford.
Brian S.Sophomore, Mathematics, Carnegie Mellon, Pittsburgh, PAFeb 4, 1996
 A good place is this place in Century III mall-- I think it's called
 Italian Village Pizza.
 My favorite place was TNT Express who I got delivery from many times,
 but now their line says they are "temporarily" closed.  Anyone know what
 happened to them?
AnonymousCarnegie Mellon, Pittsburgh, PAFeb 5, 1996
 Eric S. wrote:
 > The best place I've been to outside the city is in Mt. Lebanon, and I
 > was only there once, and it was a long time ago. I think it was called
 > Beto's, but it might be Bedo's, or something like that. The pizza was
 > good, and there was a good selection of other food, too - again not too
 > expensive. I was with my gf when I went, and she knows the directions,
 > but I don't. I can remember going through the Fort Pitt Tunnel off the
 > Parkway and taking one of the first exits (something Road?) and
 > following that road. Sorry I can't remember more.. Maybe someone else
 > can help?
 >

 Actually,there's both a Beto's and a Bado's down that way. Beto's in
 on Banksville; Bado's is a bit farther along, on Beverly. Beto's is
 mostly takeout; Bado's has a nice restaurant (and both better pizza
 and a better selection).

 However, if you are in Mt. Lebanon, you can get even better pizza at
 Caruso's, on Washington Rd. (across from the Denis Theatre).

 ******************************************************************
 Jim Mann                      [email removed]
 Transarc Corporation
 The Gulf Tower, 707 Grant Street, Pittsburgh, PA 15219  (412) 338-4442
 WWW Homepage: http://www.transarc.com/~jmann/Home.html
Bill T.Graduate School of Industrial Administr., Carnegie Mellon, Pittsburgh, PAFeb 5, 1996
 Excerpts from netnews.pgh.food: 5-Feb-96 Re: Best Pizza in Pittsburgh by
 [email removed]
 > Bado's has a nice restaurant (and both better pizza
 > and a better selection).
 >
 > However, if you are in Mt. Lebanon, you can get even better pizza at
 > Caruso's, on Washington Rd. (across from the Denis Theatre).
 >

 I've had both, and both are good. I vote for Bado's, however.
Eric S.Senior, English, Carnegie Mellon, Pittsburgh, PAFeb 5, 1996
 Excerpts from netnews.pgh.food: 5-Feb-96 Re: Best Pizza in Pittsburgh by
 "Vivian M. Benton"@psc.e
 > The restaurant you're talking about is Bado's.  Excellent pizza. They
 > have all you can eat on Wednesday's and Thursday's (for lunch). It's
 > worth the trip there. I can't tell you the name of the road either, but
 > it's pretty popular. Just call and ask for directions.  vivian
 >
 >
 Excerpts from netnews.pgh.food: 5-Feb-96 Re: Best Pizza in Pittsburgh by
 [email removed]
 > Actually,there's both a Beto's and a Bado's down that way. Beto's in
 > on Banksville; Bado's is a bit farther along, on Beverly. Beto's is
 > mostly takeout; Bado's has a nice restaurant (and both better pizza
 > and a better selection).
 >
 > However, if you are in Mt. Lebanon, you can get even better pizza at
 > Caruso's, on Washington Rd. (across from the Denis Theatre).
 >
 >

 After talking with my gf and reading some of the more recent posts, I've
 reached the conclusion that I meant Beto's. I was thinking of Banksville
 Road, and actually, when I was there, I ate at the restaurant (small,
 fairly clean) - I live too far away for practical takeout (at CMU in
 Oakland) from Mt. Lebanon. I've never been to the other two places, but
 I'll have to try them sometime.

 As for why I liked the two places, pizza isn't my _favorite_ food, but I
 just thought as far as overall quality and taste (though I'm not
 exceedingly discriminating, I can usually tell _bad_ from _good_ and in
 between), those are the two best I've had in the city. I also liked the
 price at Mineo's, which I seem to recall is one of the better bargains
 around. I haven't been to either place for a while, and don't honestly
 remember specifics about the food or prices. I never thought the pizza
 at Mineo's was _that_ greasy, but I'm used to the local delivery places
 (Domino's, Pizza Outlet, Papa John's, Larry & Carol's), almost all of
 whom have greasy pizza.

 Makes $.04 total.
 ERIC
AnonymousCarnegie Mellon, Pittsburgh, PAFeb 5, 1996
 Vivian B. wrote:
 >
 > The restaurant you're talking about is Bado's.  Excellent pizza. They
 > have all you can eat on Wednesday's and Thursday's (for lunch). It's
 > worth the trip there. I can't tell you the name of the road either, but
 > it's pretty popular. Just call and ask for directions.  vivian

 It's Beverly Road, which is also Route 19/the Yellow Belt, so it's
 easy to find.

 ******************************************************************
 Jim Mann                      [email removed]
 Transarc Corporation
 The Gulf Tower, 707 Grant Street, Pittsburgh, PA 15219  (412) 338-4442
 WWW Homepage: http://www.transarc.com/~jmann/Home.html
Gretchen M.Computer Operations, Carnegie Mellon, Pittsburgh, PAFeb 5, 1996
 The best Pizza in Pittsburgh isn't in Pittsburgh.  It's in Wheeling (1
 hr drive).  De Carlos Pizza in Elm Grove.  They don't deliver, and they
 only have two kinds -- with and without pepperoni.  The times I've had
 it the sauce was fabulous, tasted like fresh tomatos, nicely spiced
 without being over oreganoed (my complaint with most Pgh sauces), and
 with thick slices of pepperoni.

 There is a DeCarlos on RT 51 about 1/2 way between the West Liberty Ave
 and Rt 88, but I don't know if it's the same.  Have to try it some day.

 toodles, gretchen

 From [email removed] Thu Aug 14 15:45:02 EDT 1997
 Article: 35314 of rec.food.restaurants
Gregory S.Carnegie-Mellon UniverityFeb 5, 1996
 I think that if you're going to rate the pizza, you have to say
 why you like it. I know many who love Mineo's, but I personally
 cannot stand it. It's too cheesy and greasy. I have to pat it
 down with a napkin before ingesting it. Others like Vincent's for
 the same reason.

 I like Larry & Carol's and Pizza Perfectta. Both have an excellent
 sauce, which is my favorite part of a pizza. It has a tangy zest,
 and compliments pepperoni & mushrooms quite well. Both of these
 establishments make a great spinach & garlic and spinach & chicken
 pizza, too.

 My only complaints is that neither place is particularly consistent.
 When I get a good one, it's very good, when I don't, it's edible.

 Sooooooooooo, say why you like the pizza. Mineo's may be great, but
 it's not what I look for or like.
 gReg
Paul G.University of PittsburghFeb 5, 1996
 Gregory S. wrote:
 >
 >I think that if you're going to rate the pizza, you have to say
 >why you like it. I know many who love Mineo's, but I personally
 >cannot stand it. It's too cheesy and greasy. I have to pat it
 >down with a napkin before ingesting it. Others like Vincent's for
 >the same reason.

 If you're close enough to Mineo's to be considering it, try Rialto's
 which is very close.  Their pizza is very good and had some nice touches
 for the very reasonable price, like fresh sliced toppings (not a wimpy water
 logged mushroom in sight) and a wide assortment of differnt types of
 Pizza.  The feta and spinich with white sauce and garlic is to die for.

 Paul
Richard W.University of PittsburghFeb 5, 1996
 Someone wrote:

 # I think that if you're going to rate the pizza, you have to say
 # why you like it. I know many who love Mineo's, but I personally
 # cannot stand it. It's too cheesy and greasy. I have to pat it
 # down with a napkin before ingesting it. Others like Vincent's for
 # the same reason.

 # I like Larry & Carol's and Pizza Perfectta. Both have an excellent
 # sauce, which is my favorite part of a pizza. It has a tangy zest,
 # and compliments pepperoni & mushrooms quite well. Both of these
 # establishments make a great spinach & garlic and spinach & chicken
 # pizza, too.

 hmm, i always thought the worst part of L&C pizza was the sauce.
 but if you're looking for sheer vast quantities of PIZZA, you can't
 beat the pizza duo.

 you're not alone in sopping up the grease puddles on Mineo's pizza
 before eating.  i do think Vincent's is the best, but you have to be
 in a certain mood for it.  when you walk in, you take two steps down:
 one physical and one social.

 and i've been to that one out by Greentree that was mentioned.  tasted
 like the frozen Tambellini's pizza to me.  which i like, but....

 my sentimental favorite is Mama Lucia's in the Northway mall.  we
 used to go there once a week when i was a kid.

  -Rick
Vivian B.Pittsburgh Supercomputing CenterFeb 5, 1996
 >The best place I've been to outside the city is in Mt. Lebanon, and I
 >was only there once, and it was a long time ago. I think it was called
 >Beto's, but it might be Bedo's, or something like that. The pizza was
 >good, and there was a good selection of other food, too - again not too
 >expensive. I was with my gf when I went, and she knows the directions,
 >but I don't. I can remember going through the Fort Pitt Tunnel off the
 >Parkway and taking one of the first exits (something Road?) and
 >following that road. Sorry I can't remember more.. Maybe someone else
 >can help?

 The restaurant you're talking about is Bado's.  Excellent pizza. They
 have all you can eat on Wednesday's and Thursday's (for lunch). It's
 worth the trip there. I can't tell you the name of the road either, but
 it's pretty popular. Just call and ask for directions.  vivian
Diane M.Counseling & Student Development Center, Carnegie Mellon, Pittsburgh, PAFeb 6, 1996
 Pino's in Point Breeze on
 6739 Reynolds Ave.
 361-1336

 reason why:
 --I like their specialty pizzas--calazones--cheabatas(sp)
 --they have good red sauce.
 --they're crust is thin, but I do believe they have a thicker crust--Chicago.
 --they have a really good clam and asparagus pizza. I don't get the
 heavy     white sauce, I just have it scampied. (butter and garlic)
 --they are not a chain, so it's community business support thing--and
 his food is better any how, so I don't have to make any sacrafices.

 What I like best about them is that when everyone's in a pizza mood and
 I'm not I have this huge menu to choose from, and I have enjoyed trying
 they're many dishes.  I like the fact that I can get a really good
 dinner - take out or delivery - instead of cooking, or instead of
 ordering fast food.  I really enjoy their chicken parmigiana sub, and
 they're tuna steak salad.  They have great foccacio(sp) bread sandwiches
 too.  They really have much, much more than most delivery places and 9
 times out of 10, I really enjoy their food.
 I HATE anything burnt so that's my major complaint with most pizza and
 hoagie places, when the food comes out of those ovens the edges are
 usually burnt, and I find that very gross, so I always say ---and please
 don't burn it--- where ever I go, not just Pino's.

 Diane
 A Pino Regular
Louise H.Doctoral student, Chemical Engineering, Carnegie Mellon, Pittsburgh, PAFeb 6, 1996
 The best pizza in Pittsburgh is NAPOLI'S!!!!!!

 It's real good and fresh ITALIAN pizza.  Also free delivery to a fairly
 large area. (Squirrel Hill, Shadyside, etc..)

 Try it.  (Squirrel Hill on Murray)  THere use to be one on Fifth in
 Oakland, but I don't know if it's still there.

 This is one place when I left the 'burgh I missed terribly and now that
 I'm back I'm loving it.
John M.CityNet, Inc.Feb 7, 1996
 Someone wrote:
 >IMHO there is no better pizza in this or any parallel universe than
 >Vincents.  It's on Rt. 30 (off Parkway East at Forest hills).  Only open
 >in the evenings and looks like it is, or should be, condemned; but be
 >brave, go in and try the very best.
 >Jack

 I've heard a lot of people praise Vincent's Pizza on Rt 30.  I've had
 it several times, and there's absolutely nothing special about it, IMHO.

 To each his own.
James W.Doctoral student, Physics, Carnegie Mellon, Pittsburgh, PAFeb 7, 1996
 Excerpts from netnews.pgh.food: 6-Feb-96 Re: Best Pizza in Pittsburgh by
 Jeffrey T [email removed]
 > Excerpts from netnews.pgh.food: 6-Feb-96 Re: Best Pizza in Pittsburgh by
 > James W [email removed]
 > > Rialto's is quite good, especially their white pizza.  Their only fault
 > > is that my pizza is consistently cold when they deliver it so I've taken
 > > to only getting pizza from them when I can pick it up.
 >
 > Really?  I've never had a problem with Rialto's, and I've been getting
 > food from there since it opened.  I think Rialto's is the best place to
 > have pizza delivered from (to CMU in Oakland, anyway)... Good pizza,
 > fair prices, relatively quick delivery.

 All those are true and I've been having pizza delivered from them since
 they opened (I remember having to give them directions not only to Wean
 Hall but to CMU the first few times), but after the first month or two
 they were open every pizza I've received at CMU or at home in Squirrel
 Hill has been cold.

 > (Ever order from Larry and Carol's?  talk about slow delivery...)

 L&C's is amazingly slow and inconsistent about it so you can't plan
 on waiting an hour--maybe this time it'll come in 40 minutes or maybe
 it'll be 80.  Good pizza though.

 > For take-out or eat-in, I prefer Aiello's (sp?) in Squirrel Hill.

 I'll pick up pizza from Aiello's if I'm walking home.  I can't notice
 any major differences between them and Napoli's or Mineo's, but it's
 closer to where I live than Napoli's and seems to be the fastest of
 the three for me to get in and out of.  If I'm in Oakland, I'll usually
 go to Sorrento's which has a good deep dish pizza (which they call
 Chicago style though it isn't).

 James (http://www-hep.phys.cmu.edu:8001/~walden/home.html)
  "Truth decays into beauty, while beauty soon becomes merely charm.  Charm
   ends up as strangeness, and even that doesn't last, but up and down are
   forever." - The Laws of Physics
roger M.The Microsoft Network (msn.com)Feb 7, 1996
 mINEO'S IS THE BEST IN MY OPINION AND IT IS NOT GREASY!
 THIS IS OLIVE OIL AND NATURAL JUICES THAT COME FROM THE CHEESE WHICH
 UNLIKE A LOT OF OTHER PLACES IS REAL AND NOT A CHEESE SUBSTITUTE
Paul H.School of Computer Science, Carnegie MellonFeb 7, 1996
 Well, we really seem to be reaching consensus on the pizza issue :-)

 I've lived in Boston, Long Island, and the San Francisco Bay, and
 Pittsburgh has the worst pizza of any of these communities, in general.
 What is commonly regarded as excellent pizza here would be considered
 mediocre in many other cities.

 My favorite pizza places here are not the most popular ones:

 Very good pizza:

     East End Food Coop: very good individual size pizzas.
       Good crust, nice choice of vegetarian ingredients.
       I think they serve it only from 11am - 4pm.

     Holiday Inn, Oakland  (their restaurant food is surprisingly good)

     Pino's, Reynolds St, Point Breeze.
     I like their Calabrese pizza.  Nice, thin crust, good ingredients,
     not overloaded with cheese or sauce.

 Tolerable pizza:

     Vincent's: meat too salty, often overcooked, bad aftertaste
     Mineo's: unremarkable

 Yuck:
     Domino's, Little Caesar's

 ----
 If you ever want world class pizza, try Pauline's Pizza in San Francisco,
 or Zachary's in Berkeley CA.
Margo X.Alcoa Technical CenterFeb 8, 1996
 Nico's Recovery Room - 176 Pearl Street in Pittsburgh's Bloomfield section.
 It's a neighborhood bar/restaurant that serves the best of Greek and American
 dishes.....and Greek pizza is one of their specialties....it's a delightful
 experience.
Ritesh B.Robotics Institute, Carnegie Mellon, Pittsburgh, PAFeb 8, 1996
 Little Italy in Oakland has changed owners again and IMHO there pizza
 is pretty good, almost kickass! Their dough makes a world of
 difference.

 Ritesh

 The lit
Bradley H.Telecommunications, Carnegie Mellon, Pittsburgh, PAFeb 14, 1996
 vincent's on forbes avenue squirrel hill is bad--stick to route 30 for
 original taste.  but fyi, figure out which guy is vince, watch him go
 into men's room and emerge later with same flour dust on his hands then
 go back to flying the pizza pies.  and you wondered what that extra
 special taste on the pie was...

 brad
who E.Nauticom - Internet Access ProviderFeb 15, 1996
 Someone wrote:
 : The best place I've been to in the city is Mineo's, on Murray Avenue in
 : Squirrel Hill. Take the Squirrel Hill exit off the Parkway (exit 8). The
 : pizza is excellent, there's other kinds of food, and the price is really
 : good.
 : ERIC

 I live close to mineo's and i have to have that pizza once a week (white
 pizza, with sliced tomatoes and mushrooms and extra cheese) BUT- (allways
 a but), if you don't like salty foods you may not like it.. lots of
 people complain about it being too salty.... BUT the crust is wonderful
 and that really is a big factor in what makes a great pizza for me. you
 can get half white and half red which is nice, most places don't do that.
 chow... callas
Share this page