Skip to main content
The Kitchen Archive

Eats Archive › Wisconsin › Milwaukee

Milwaukee, WI

Milwaukee??

4 posts · Oct 14, 1994 to Oct 19, 1994

Michael R.CRL Dialup Internet AccessOct 14, 1994
Pama M. wrote:
> Another reporter is going to Milwaukee in a week or so, and would like a
> restaurant suggestion or two. She likes Italian. Any ideas?
>
> Thanks again.

It's not Italian but the Pleasant Valley Inn in West Allis is nothing short of fabulous! I'm probably somewhat biased since I am the chef's brother, however, they did just get listed as one of Milwaukee's top 25 restaurants and received a wonderful ***1/2 star review in the Milwaukee Journal's Sunday Magazine section (see The Milwaukee Journal,June 12, 1994,p.23). There are daily chef specials which usually include a pasta dish and occasionally there are theme nights!!

John (my brother, the chef) prides himself on some of the finest beef in Milwaukee and it's always prepared to perfection.

I could probably go on for too long and damage my credibility, so let me just say that if you should decide to stop by be sure to ask to see the chef and tell him I sent you. He loves his job and his customers!

Michael Rutchik
[email removed]

Pleasant Valley Inn
Tue thru Thur: 5 to 9PM
Fri & Sat: 5 to 10PM
Sun: 4 to 8PM
9801 W. Dakota Street
West Allis, WI
(414) 321-4321
Chef: John Rutchik
[email removed]
Chris K.Fisher-Rosemount, Rosemount Inc.Oct 17, 1994
Pama M. wrote:
: Another reporter is going to Milwaukee in a week or so, and would like a : restaurant suggestion or two. She likes Italian. Any ideas? : : Thanks again.

While not Italian, she might want to give Sanford's a try. We went there a year ago and had a marvelous meal.  Midwest cuisine at its finest.  I believe Bon Appetit did a story on it a couple of years ago.  Also, if I remember correctly, the head chef made the canoli desserts for the Julia Childs birthday party shown on PBS a while back.  A truly great restaurant. (Oh, it IS expensive too).
David S.University of Wisconsin - Milwaukee, Computing Services DivisionOct 17, 1994
Chris K. wrote:

>: Another reporter is going to Milwaukee in a week or so, and would like a
>: restaurant suggestion or two. She likes Italian. Any ideas?
>:
>: Thanks again.
>
>While not Italian, she might want to give Sanford's a try. We went
>there a year ago and had a marvelous meal.  Midwest cuisine at its
>finest.  I believe Bon Appetit did a story on it a couple of years
>ago.  Also, if I remember correctly, the head chef made the canoli
>desserts for the Julia Childs birthday party shown on PBS a while
>back.  A truly great restaurant. (Oh, it IS expensive too).

      Sanford is as good a restaurant as you will find in Milwaukee
      OR Chicago. And with NY prices  :)

      Italian in Milwaukee:

      Bartalottas---  Not Il Mulino or Il Nido but probably the
                  best place in Milwaukee for Italian.

      Mangia--    Actually about an hour south of Milwaukee in
                  Kenosha. Pretty good if you order the right
                  things and get lucky.

      Marangellis--     Housed in the 1st Wisconsin building where Sanford
                  used to work before he opened his own place. Lousy
                  if you ask me...but a nice looking place. [I'll
                  probably end up in the Milwaukee River for
                  posting this one, if you know what I mean.  :)  ]

      Louises--   The current trendy hotspot where women go to meet
                  lawyers and lawyers go to meet women and women
                  lawyers go to meet...get the picture? Its a chain
                  out of LA, I think. And the quality of food is
                  what you'd expect from a chain. Its a beautiful
                  place full of Beautiful People [ugh!] but it
                  isn't much better than a Chancery or a Red Lobster,
                  IMO.

      With the exception of Bartolottas, I would drive to Chicago
      to Tuscany, or even Cocco Pazzo,  or any number of superior
      Italian restaurants before spending another nickel at any of these
      places.

      Of course, bad restaurants can be learning experiences in themselves.

      :)

--spencer
Karl H.Oct 19, 1994
> Pama M. wrote:
> : Another reporter is going to Milwaukee in a week or so, and would like a
> : restaurant suggestion or two. She likes Italian. Any ideas?
> :
> : Thanks again.
>
  Sorry - don't know Italian but if she likes German,
  Maders is excellent.  One of my favorite German restaurants (and we
  have a few good ones here in Chicago).  Right across the street from
  Usingers', which is a fairly neat place to check out as well.
Share this page