Skip to main content
The Kitchen Archive

Eats Archive › Pennsylvania › Pittsburgh

Pittsburgh, PA

Rudy's Subs on Murray

2 posts · Jan 30, 1995 to Jan 31, 1995

Jeffrey F.Carnegie Library of PittsburghJan 30, 1995
 Saturday night we swung by the new Rudy's Subs on Murray Avenue in
 Sq Hill and picked up two sandwiches.  One was an italian with
 everything including hot peppers, the other was a Rudy's special
 steak (comes with mushrooms and peppers) with lettuce and tomato.

 The steak was nothing to write home about--although this may be
 because it was 20 minutes old by the time we got around to eating
 it.  Still it was filling.  The italian was a good italian. The
 sandwiches are very large. Two sandwiches and an order of onion
 rings fed three of us with leftovers.  Large sandwiches are on
 something like a small loaf of bread (a bit larger than your typical
 large SUBWAY roll).  The place may be a bit pricey. The two
 sandwiches and the onion rings came to about $14.  I've no
 idea how that compares to other places or how the size/value
 comparison works out.  But I will say you could do worse. Also,
 although the last two places to occupy this spot were Kosher
 the pork based cold cuts in my italian indicate Rudy's isn't.

 A bit of history from the brothers who own the franchise.  20
 or so years ago this location was the origianl Rudy's. Then they
 were accross the street where Aiello's is now.  Then the Sq. Hill
 business dropped off and franchises in places like Swissvale opened.
 So now they are back where they started.   I'm likely to go back.

 They have menus and you can phone ahead for takeout.

 Jeff
James W.Doctoral student, Physics, Carnegie Mellon, Pittsburgh, PAJan 31, 1995
 Excerpts from netnews.pgh.food: 30-Jan-95 Rudy's Subs on Murray by
 Jeffrey P. Fortescue@clp
 > Saturday night we swung by the new Rudy's Subs on Murray Avenue in
 > Sq Hill and picked up two sandwiches.  One was an italian with
 > everything including hot peppers, the other was a Rudy's special
 > steak (comes with mushrooms and peppers) with lettuce and tomato.

 I went to Rudy's tonight for dinner and had the chicken Italian, while
 my friend had the special steak you mentioned.  While both the sandwiches
 were large, they weren't particularly good.  The bread wasn't good,
 especially when compared to the bread on subs from Sorrento's or Uncle
 Sam's.  The meat
 was okay, but there weren't enough vegetables to notice and the tomato sauce
 was rather bland and boring.  The onion rings reminded my friend of his
 dining hall experiences as an undergraduate and I wasn't sure if I'd say
 they were
 even that good.

 All in all, I'm hoping that yet another restaurant will appear on that corner
 and that it'll finally be a good one.  I'm going to stick with Sorrento's or
 Uncle Sam's (or maybe even Subway) for my subs and avoid Rudy's.

 James
  "Truth decays into beauty, while beauty soon becomes merely charm.  Charm
   ends up as strangeness, and even that doesn't last, but up and down are
   forever." - The Laws of Physics
Share this page