Skip to main content
The Kitchen Archive

Eats Archive › Pennsylvania › Pittsburgh

Pittsburgh, PA

Pizza

9 posts · Jul 14, 1994 to Dec 10, 2003

Derek W.Junior, Math/Computer Science, Carnegie Mellon, Pittsburgh, PAJul 14, 1994
 I am the epitome of a pizza loving person. I have pizza _at_least_ 3
 time a week. A typical day could be: cold for breakfast with OJ,
 cold/warm/hot for lunch, and cold/warm/hot for dinner. This would be a
 good day for me.

 Anyways, I eat just about any pizza, but trust me I have my limits, and
 my favorites. Chains, like Italian Oven and Papa John's, have okay
 pizza, better then Domino's (gag!), but they all lake that handmade
 touch. The fresh dough, the ripe tomatoes stewing into a wonderful
 sauce, the freshly grated cheeses (and lots of them). The chains can't
 compare.

 Now, having lived in Pgh for 3 years in the Shadyside/Oakland area, the
 best pizza I have found is at Aiello's on Murray Avenue. the crust is
 perfect, not too thin, the cheese is plentyful, and the sauce is
 perfect. add pepperoni and I will love you forever. :-)

 I'm hungry.

 Derek
Mara L.Pittsburgh Public SchoolsNov 4, 1996
 Many folks here in Pittsburgh, (including myself) think that Mineo's
 Pizza, on Murray Avenue in Squirrel Hill has the best pizza around.....

 -Mara
Jinan T.Completely Dis-...Nov 11, 1996
 James S. wrote:
 >
 > On 04-Nov-96 in Re: Pizza
 > Someone wrote:
 > >Many folks here in Pittsburgh, (including myself) think that Mineo's
 > >Pizza, on Murray Avenue in Squirrel Hill has the best pizza around.....
 >
 > I second the motion.
 > ------------------------------

 I'll third that opinion, but add a bit... A lot of my friends don't
 understand my love of Mineo's when the much better (their opinion)
 Napoli is right up the street. Sometimes, I'm inclined to agree with
 them, but mostly I'm not.

 I lived above Mineo's for a year and ate there nearly every other day
 for lunch. It was pure heaven (and extremely hot in the summer when the
 oven's were going non-stop.) :)

 Ryan Little
AnonymousNov 6, 2000
 The consensus seems to be either Mineo's in Squirrel Hill, or Vincent's (on
 Ardmore Blvd).

 I also recommend Pizza Italia on Liberty Ave in Bloomfield.

 Someone wrote:

 > where is the best pizza in the pgh.area
 >
 >
Jim M.IBM CorporationNov 7, 2000
 Someone wrote:
 >The consensus seems to be either Mineo's in Squirrel Hill, or Vincent's (on
 >Ardmore Blvd).

 Well, that seems to be the consensus of folks who live east of the city
 anyway. But I'd stack the pizza at Caruso's or Bado's (both in Mt. Lebanon)
 up against either.
MarkNov 7, 2000
 Marcy wrote:

 > Intersting. I live in the South Hills but I'd still put Mineos (which also
 > has a branch in Mt. Lebanon, BTW) head and shoulders above Bado's...where is
 > Caruso's, I'd like to try it!
 >
 > Marcy

    Caruso's is across the street from Mineo's, about half a block away....Right
 across from the Dennis Theatre. I haven't been there in years , but they have
 excellent white pizza.
     I also reccomend Mineo's , or my personal favorite Campiti's in Dormont,
 located on Potomac Avenue.
               -----Mark
Christine B.Univ. of PittsburghNov 9, 2000
 Someone wrote:

 > Marcy wrote:
 >
 > > Intersting. I live in the South Hills but I'd still put Mineos (which also
 > > has a branch in Mt. Lebanon, BTW) head and shoulders above Bado's...where is
 > > Caruso's, I'd like to try it!
 > >
 > > Marcy
 >
 >    Caruso's is across the street from Mineo's, about half a block
 away....Right
 > across from the Dennis Theatre. I haven't been there in years , but they have
 > excellent white pizza.
 >     I also reccomend Mineo's , or my personal favorite Campiti's in Dormont,
 > located on Potomac Avenue.
 >               -----Mark

 I think Don Campiti's pizza is just OK (I live two blocks away). I do love
 the fact that they don't use boxes, just a cardboard round, and a brown
 paper bag expertly pulled over it, puffed & twisted closed!

 I like Bado's pizza a lot, but I find their restaurant distressingly yukky
 these days (dirty, loud music and weak service). It used to be a favorite
 Sunday night-too-tired-to-cook place :-(     Take out is still OK, you can
 get great stuff on the pizza.

 For fashionable pizza, the wood-oven stuff at Pizzaiolo's in Mt. Lebanon
 (near the Denis also) is really great, but there is always a line to get
 in.

 Davio's annex in Beechview did great pizza for take-out. I think that has
 moced to their sister restaurant, Palio, also in beechview.

 Christine

 Christine Berliner
 [email removed]
Will D.Knology BroadbandDec 6, 2003
 From: Derek J Wahila
 Subject: Pizza

 I am the epitome of a pizza loving person. I have pizza _at_least_ 3
 time a week. A typical day could be: cold for breakfast with OJ,
 cold/warm/hot for lunch, and cold/warm/hot for dinner. This would be a
 good day for me.

 Anyways, I eat just about any pizza, but trust me I have my limits, and
 my favorites. Chains, like Italian Oven and Papa John's, have okay
 pizza, better then Domino's (gag!), but they all lake that handmade
 touch. The fresh dough, the ripe tomatoes stewing into a wonderful
 sauce, the freshly grated cheeses (and lots of them). The chains can't
 compare.

 Now, having lived in Pgh for 3 years in the Shadyside/Oakland area, the
 best pizza I have found is at Aiello's on Murray Avenue. the crust is
 perfect, not too thin, the cheese is plentyful, and the sauce is
 perfect. add pepperoni and I will love you forever. :-)

 I'm hungry.

 Derek

 Stop by Pizza Roma for a pizza... completely handmade, with sauce made from
 the recipe of Ben's mother, hand tossed dough, and loaded with toppings...
 Will
NobodyMarconiDec 10, 2003
 > Now, having lived in Pgh for 3 years in the Shadyside/Oakland area, the
 > best pizza I have found is at Aiello's on Murray Avenue. the crust is
 > perfect, not too thin, the cheese is plentyful, and the sauce is
 > perfect. add pepperoni and I will love you forever. :-)
 >
 >
 > I'm hungry.
 >
 > Derek

 Now I'M hungry for pizza.

 The best I've had is in Greensburg (a bit east of Pgh, but worth the drive)
 Jioios Pizza.

 Wonderful sauce and the crust is thin, crispy, and just a bit sweet.

 http://www.jioios.com/
Share this page