Skip to main content
The Kitchen Archive

Eats Archive › Pennsylvania › Pittsburgh

Pittsburgh, PA

Casbah

10 posts · Oct 28, 1995 to May 14, 1996

Lillian B.Carnegie Mellon UniversityOct 28, 1995
 Just went to Casbah (the new creation of Mad Mex owners).  The food was
 terrific, extremely tasty.  The decor of the main part of the restaurant
 is amazing.  They have beautiful tile work and put big bucks into it.  We
 had butternut squash soup which was excellent and goat cheese and peppers
 as an appetizer.  Their wine list is extensive and you can order a
 "flight" which is a sample of 3 wines if you don't know what to order.  I
 had carrot gnocci for dinner and my husband had lamb and pears.  The
 dinner was excellent.  Entrees range from $8.50 to $18.00.
 I recommend making reservations and requesting a seat upstairs if possible.
Lillian B.Carnegie Mellon UniversityOct 28, 1995Subject: Re: Casbah (where it is)
 Casbah is in Shadyside on Highland Avenue and yes, the Mad Mex people have
 a restaurant called Kaya in the Strip (20th & Smallman ????) where they
 serve their interpretation of carribean food.  It is very good and
 reasonably priced.
Boyd S.Doctoral student, Chemical Engineering, Carnegie Mellon, Pittsburgh, PANov 1, 1995
 I went to The Casbah last night with 8 other people for my birthday. All
 in all, the food was great.  Service was REAL slow.  We got there
 areound 7:15 and did not leave until 10.  It was not really that crowded.

 For appetizers, we had the goat cheese in filo which I strongly suggest,
 the Portugese sausage soup, and  quail.  All were reported as being very
 good. They also gave us fresh break with olive oil for dunking.  Very
 good bread.

 Most of us had beer but I had a flight of white wine (3 2 ounce servings
 of different whites.) I enjoyed this. They had a choice of a white or
 red flight with the wines already preselected. Beers start at $3 and go
 to $12. Wines are somewhat expensive.

 For dinner we had grilled game hen (this is what I had and I thought it
 was excellent), the crepes, a pasta dish where the pasta looks kind of
 like a straw before you cook it, a barbecues potatoe stuffed pasta dish,
 and stuffed pork chops. I only tried my game hen, but the guy who had
 the pork chops said that they were the best he has every had. The
 entrees are $9 to $19 with the average around $15.

 All in all I like the place very much. The service was slow however. I
 hope to go back soon.

 BOYD SAFRIT
Boyd S.Doctoral student, Chemical Engineering, Carnegie Mellon, Pittsburgh, PANov 2, 1995
 I am not sure of the exact location. But if you go down Walnut St.
 towards S. Highland Ave, then turn left onto S. Highland, go about 2
 blocks, Casbah is on your right. The building is kind of pink-adobe
 looking. Sorry, that is the best I can do.
 BOYD SAFRIT
Andrew P.Doctoral student, Social & Decision Sciences, Carnegie Mellon, Pittsburgh, PANov 2, 1995
 We stopped by Casbah the other night.  I can't say our experience was
 all that great, although it certainly wasn't as bad as our first
 experience with Kaya, and Kaya got much better over time.

 First, if you plan on going to Casbah, by all means, make a reservation!
  We didn't (from experience with Mad Mex and Kaya, we didn't think they
 took reservations), and we ended up waiting 40 minutes for a table.
 This was extremely upsetting given that the hostess estimated 15-20
 minutes.  After that, things just got slower.

 The restaurant as a whole is beautiful.  Don't let the size of the
 upstairs fool you, they have plenty of seating downstairs.  Also, it
 should be fun once they open up the patio next spring.  As with their
 other restaurants, the bar is really nice.  And the noise level is much
 lower, as you'd expect from a fancier restaurant.

 The food started out with whimper.  Pasty white bread and "olive oil."
 Actually, the olive oil was so pale and flavorless, they could've been
 serving us Canola Oil, for all we knew.  If they are doing
 Mediterranean, borrow from the Italians, and put some rosemary or just
 about anything in the olive oil, folks.  And beef up the bread.

 We also had the butternut squash soup.  It was very good, as was the
 goat's cheese with filo.  We felt, however, that the entree menu was a
 bit sparse.  I remember Kaya's beginnings, though, and it was the same
 story there.  The owners eventually heard people grumbling about Kaya,
 and remedied the situation.  I agree that the vegetarian menu was drab.
 I don't usually go to restaurants expecting a huge selection of
 vegetarian entrees, but the ones at Casbah were not all that
 interesting, given the reputation of Mad Mex and Kaya.  Those
 restaurants have a large vegetarian following, and it would seem that
 the owners would want to tap into that for Casbah.  Also, a name like
 Casbah suggests to me something exotic, interesting, and new.  In our
 experience, that wasn't delivered.

 Hope this is helpful.

 Andy

 PS:  The deserts were delicious.
AnonymousTelerama Public Access Internet, Pittsburgh, PANov 3, 1995
 Casbah is in the vicinity of Shadyside Plaza (little shopping center
 with Tasty Chinese and Pizza Hut delivery) across the street from the
 Basic Concepts store that is going out of business and just before you
 go across the little bridge into East Liberty. Color Tile and Willi's
 Ski Warehouse are next door, but don't park there as you'll get towed.

 Parking on the street is spotty. They advise parking in a tiny unpaved
 lot that is the next right after Shadyside Plaza. This lot only holds
 about 20 cars and is often full or near full, even at odd times in the
 middle of the day. This is across from the Christian Science Reading
 Room. If you park in this lot, *beware* there are huge pieces of
 uneven concrete at the top of this lot that could rip the oil pan,
 etc. right off your car if you don't approach it gently. I guess there
 used to be an old house there and this was the front walk.

 The food? I really enjoyed the lamb with cinaminnon cous cous this
 past Monday lunch, but the service was slow and the place not that
 busy. I got the feeling my waiter was on his first job ever. The wine
 flights are interesting and fun. Unfortunately, if you go into the bar
 for a wine flight in the middle of the day (between lunch and dinner)
 there is NO food available at all--not even bread and olive oil or
 "goldfish" snacks in a bowl to cleanse your palette during your wine
 flight tasting. Hope they change this. I enjoy the decor and found the
 staff friendly and knowledgeable.

 Pam in Oakland
Mark M.Dept of Philosophy, U. of PittsburghNov 3, 1995
 Andrew P. wrote about Casbah:

 >The food started out with whimper.  Pasty white bread and "olive oil."
 >Actually, the olive oil was so pale and flavorless, they could've been
 >serving us Canola Oil, for all we knew.  If they are doing
 >Mediterranean, borrow from the Italians, and put some rosemary or just
 >about anything in the olive oil, folks.  And beef up the bread.

 I think you're being unfair.  The oil was olive oil, as announced, and
 the bread was ok.  It's white bread, but many perfectly good breads are
 white.  If your motto is, "borrow from the Italians," what Casbah does
 fits that squarely.  It's not as if Italians turn their noses up at
 unflavoured olive oil.  It has a taste of its own, one that does differ
 from that of canola oil.  And there are many white Italian breads.

 Mark McCullagh
Bill F.Telerama Public Access Internet, Pittsburgh, PANov 9, 1995
 In article , Jane Aronson Manning
 Someone wrote:

 @There are many white Italian breads, but they typically have a quite
 @different taste and texture from the mushy white stuff that Casbah servs.
 @
 @I thought the food there was on the whole pretty good, but, as is the
 @case w/ many Pittsburgh restaurants that have otherwise good food, the
 @bread was just awful.
 @
 @It seems like it would be easy enough for restaurants to serve decent
 @bread in Pittsburgh, like restaurants in many other cities do.  Someone
 @just needs to explain to them how bad their bread is.
 @
 @And there's even a place that can sell good breads to restaurants in
 @Pittsburgh:  Bread Works.  The restaurants just need to get a clue.

 Actually, all the bread we serve is top of the line Breadworks bread.  The
 "pasty white bread" is Breadwork's Ciabatta, a classical Italian bread.

 I agree.  Breadworks does make excelent bread.  As a chef, I wouldn't buy
 bread from any other bakery in town.

 Bill Fuller
 Executive Chef, Casbah
Bill F.Telerama Public Access Internet, Pittsburgh, PANov 9, 1995
 In article , Mark McCullagh
 Someone wrote:

 Someone wrote:
 @>> The ciabatta [at Casbah] is much different in texture and taste
 @>> than the Rustic Italian bread also made by the Breadworks and probably
 @>> is what the previous "reviewers" are used to calling italian bread.
 @
 @>Maybe Casbah has changed their bread.
 @
 @Maybe there's no such thing as "their" bread, maybe they just choose from
 @several different kinds of bread that they have on hand.  In fact,
 @believe it or not, this is what they do, for when I went there I had
 @bread of two different kinds.  One was focaccia, I think, but then I'm
 @not a breadworks fanatic so I probably am not qualified to say anything.

 Perhaps I can clear this up.  Our house bread is Breadworks' ciabatta.
 However, in our first week or so of business (we've been open two weeks
 this Friday) we had to work out the kinks in the ordering, including the
 bread.  Some nights we ran out of Ciabatta and had to use the focaccia and
 any other bread we had on hand. However, things are calming down and we
 have ciabatta every day possible.

 @
 @>Here's how Ciabatta usually looks:
 @(Lecture deleted.)
 @
 @>Here's how the bread at Casbah when I went there looked:
 @(Description of non-Ciabatta bread deleted.)
 @
 @>Which way did the bread that you saw there last night look?  If it's the
 @>first way, then it's different bread than they had last week.  If it's
 @>the second way, then it amazes me that 'burghers call that ciabatta.
 @
 @So far, no "'burghers" *have* called it ciabatta, so you can conserve
 @your amazement energy for some other occasion on which to feel superior
 @to Pittsburghers, e.g. the next occasion on which you go to a restaurant
 @serving bread of a sort you are not familiar with.

 Actually the owners of Breadworks are 'Burghers from way back.  And they
 call it ciabatta.

 Bill Fuller
Cheryl M.Pittsburgh Public SchoolsMay 14, 1996
 ate there Fri. night.
 The appearance and taste of
 soft shell crabs (the special) were destroyed because they were scorched.
 Even I -- a non-cook -- know that if butter is heated too long or at too
 high heat, it scorches and has to be pitched and the pan cleaned.
 I did answer the server's inquiry about "how is everything?" by
 suggesting that the crabs were just too dark, and she replaced them by 2
 that were only slightly better.  The sauce was tangy enough to cover the
 scorched taste though.  At an entree price of $25, I'd expect better.
 The lemon tart's crust was soggy, even the top part that didn't touch the
 lemon part.  Again, for $2.50, I wouldn't be offended, but at
 $4-something, I expect close to perfection.
 Butternut squash soup was good.
 I'd heard good things about Casbah and expected better.
 Service was good, and pleasant.
Share this page