Skip to main content
The Kitchen Archive

Eats Archive › Barbecue

Barbecue

Piedmont Barbecue Report

1 post · Apr 27, 1999

Robert W.Techs 'R' UsApr 27, 1999
NNTP-Posting-Date: Tue, 27 Apr 1999 18:27:11 EDT
Xref: pale-rider.INS.CWRU.Edu alt.food.barbecue:10113

Your N. wrote:

> Apologies for not posting sooner. I did promise a report, and it took
> some gentle chiding from Bill Loftin to get me off my bbq-padded butt
> and post.
>
> So, anyway, here's the report:
>
> 1. Lexington Barbecue: I've been waiting at least 8 years to try this
> place. The only other time I was in the area it was on a Sunday, when
> many bbq joints are closed. I ended up at the first place I found open,
> which I believe was Smoky Joe's, but that was so many years ago I won't
> even venture any comments.
>
> As for Lexington Barbecue, it was worth the wait. We got two large trays
> of chopped coarse outside (or "brown") meat. I have never tasted such
> succulent pig. Big chunks, most with browned skin that provides a great
> contrast to the juicy inside meat. The sauce (known as dip) is extremely
> thin, predominantly vinegar with just a hint of ketchup. It needed
> nothing else. The slaw is chopped fine, and slightly red as well. The
> hushpuppies -- according to my wife, who is not a big hushpuppy eater --
> are excellent. Smaller than most, with a pleasing crunch. The tea is
> less sweet than that found along the I-95 Eastern NC BBQ trail, so we
> liked it more.
>
> Overall, easily one of the best barbecue meals I've ever had.
>
> 2. Staymey's, Greensboro. To make comparisons easier, we got the same
> meal: two trays. The bbq was chopped finer, since I didnt see coarse on
> the menu. It was quite tasty, but not quite up to Lexington's standards.
> The slaw had more bite than Lexington's. I'd give it a teeny edge. My
> wife found the hush puppies to be inferior to Lexington's. Bonus here
> was the peach cobbler, which comes in individual servings. She liked it
> a lot. The tea was again very good. Overall, a close runner up. Maybe
> Lexington spoiled us. But if you're going to a game at the Greensboro
> Coliseum, it's right across the street.
>
> Both places are easy to get to, relative to other top bbq spots.
> Lexington is right on the Business 85-29-70 loop just south of
> Lexington, while Staymey's is on High Point Rd., just about a mile off
> I-40.
>
> Next month I have to drive through NC again, and I hope to try Short
> Sugar's in Reidsville, and probably one or two other spots.
>
> Bob Wells

Short Sugar's is good but I like Fuzzy's in Madison much better. Stay away from the Fuzzy's in Eden - the bbq is not cooked on the premises, it's trucked over from Madison. Sometimes the taste suffers.

-robert-
Share this page