Skip to main content
The Kitchen Archive

Eats Archive › Washington › Seattle

Seattle, WA

OK (Corral?) BBQ

2 posts · Aug 24, 1998 to Sep 1, 1998

Wes N.Airnews.net! at Internet AmericaAug 24, 1998
 Abuse-Reports-To: abuse at airmail.net to report improper postings
 NNTP-Proxy-Relay: library.airnews.net
 NNTP-Posting-Time: Mon Aug 24 10:05:08 1998
 NNTP-Posting-Host: cf=-u+CQrX0JkO?0d%T0Be1BFCh,,>Bl.F%+TMKB (Encoded at Airnews!)
 Mime-Version: 1.0
 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii
 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
 X-Newsreader: Forte Agent 1.5/32.451
 Xref:  seattle.eats:5297

 Curt N. wrote:

 >Yeah, but is the "Q" any good?
 >
 >Gotta give the details. Bigger isn't always better. :-)

 Not, IMHO... and real 'Q it ain't, period.  Decent side dishes, but
 the ribs were mushy and flavorless - as if they'd been parboiled
 before geing grilled.  Other meats were equally uninspiring.

 I'm not sure how they're actually doing their stuff these days
 (they've moved twice over the last couple of years and may have
 changed their equipment and methods with the moves) but at the
 original Greenwood location (which they've now back to) the ribs were
 quickly grilled (like 20 minutes) over an alderwood fire.  As any true
 BBQ afficionado knows you can't do *real* BBQ ribs in anything less
 than 2-3 hours (5-7 hours is even better).  Thicker cuts like brisket
 and pork shoulder need 12-24 hours to produce the combination of smoke
 infusion, carmelized sweetness and juicy tenderness that make real 'Q
 so outstanding.  You simply cannot achieve the flavor and texture any
 other way!

 Unfortunately most folks around here have never had real BBQ and don't
 know the difference.  Even in the south many of the old standards are
 falling by the wayside.  And it's easy to understand why - who want's
 to (and can afford to) spend 6-24 hours tending a wood fired pit and
 then serve the product (which has lost 30-40% of its weight in the
 cooking process) at lunch-time special prices.  No wonder that many
 traditional southern BBQ joints are closing their doors.

 Personally, I don't know of any place in the N.W. that serves *real*
 BBQ.  Peco's Pit is the closest I've had, but even it falls short.
 Probably your best bet is to find a friend who BBQ's as a hobby.
 Another possibility would be to stop by one of the Pacific NW BBQ
 Association competitions and try to cadge a taste from one of the
 competitors.  Once you've had sweet, smokey slow cooked 'Q - sauce on
 the side, please - you'll have a hard time settling for anything else.

 - Wes

 Wes Neuenschwander
 Seattle, WA, US
BillboNot OrganizedSep 1, 1998
 Digg wrote:

 > If it’s Q in the Ballard/Greenwood area you’re looking for then check out
 > Mr. Hall’s BBQ.  Close to NW 73rd on 15th NW in Ballard.  It’s better than
 > OK Corral although not as good as the BBQ place that used to be on 15th NW
 > across from Ballard High, IMHO.  The meet is slow cooked and flavorful.  I’m
 > so-so about the sauce.  Still it’s the best Q close to my home.

 I enjoyed the pork san at Mr Hall's.  Nice and sloppy. Last week I got all
 excited about finally getting down to Pecos Pit ...the pork was cooked
 nicely, but it lacked the zing that only hickory can provide.  And the hot
 BBQ sauce overpowered it. (Maybe I'll try the beef next time).  Dixie's
 (in Bellevue) has a decent pork san, too.  The last rack of ribs I had a
 OK Corral (springtime) wasn't as good as most that I have done myself, and
 they were out of greens!  There's no excuse for not havin' greens!  Now
 there is a relatively new place at 145th and Aurora that I mean to try.  I
 drive by  often and today I noticed a shed behind it emitting glorious
 smoke. (Sorry, but the name escapes me at this time).  And I've had other:
 Brick Pit in Everett...pleasant, lacking character.  And the place on US 2
 in Sultan...nice chicken, but again the pork loses out.

 Having lived in the South for 5 years, I have yet to eat any BBQ here in
 Seattle that rivals REAL  southern BBQ.  Alder works fine for fish and
 chicken, but  not for pork.  You need hickory.  I'm convinced of it.

 If anyone has had any killer BBQ lately, let me know!

 Thanks!
 Billbo at
 [email removed]
 (remove NO SPAM to email)
Share this page