Skip to main content
The Kitchen Archive

Eats Archive › Washington › Seattle

Seattle, WA

Best Pizza in Seattle

8 posts · May 22, 1998 to Jun 1, 1998

Stephen G.University of Washington, SeattleMay 22, 1998
  Someone wrote:
 >Are we referring to Atlantic Street Pizza on the Ave around 52nd?
 >The last time I got a pizza there I can't remember if it was good or not.
 >(I think it was)  The reason is the people that were working there so
 >obviously could not give a rats ass as to whether or not me or anyone else
 >gave them their business.

 That's the service I expect at any pizza place around the UW. Service at
 the Magnolia Atlantic St is better.
AnonymousMay 27, 1998
 May I throw in the Northlake Tavern down in the University District?  Last
 time I had pizza there it was excellent.
 I've also found superb pizza at Teo's Mia Roma in the Bothell/Kenmore area.
RPetersonICGNetcomMay 28, 1998
 Olympia Pizza on 45th in Wallingford is awesome pizza! Northlake is good
 however like all the other pizza haunts, it gives you that greasy feeling
 after you've eaten their pizza. Olympia Pizza on the otherhand does not give
 you that greasy stomach feeling after eating and it is delicious! They also
 don't skimp on their toppings! HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!

 BTW, I agree that Atlantic Pizza is horrible & their restaurants are dirty!
ThamnuMay 29, 1998
 Piecora's at 14th & E Madison gets my vote. Their fresh garlic topping is
 outstanding.  There is also a waitress in there with beautiful legs, if you
 happen to be lucky enough to dine there when she's wearing a skirt instead of
 jeans.
Laurel G.University of WashingtonMay 30, 1998
 Hey, how about Pete's Pizza?  It's on 51st in the U. District, they've
 got excellent Pizza and great calzones.
AnonymousMay 31, 1998
 Just had last night some great pizza...

 Pudge's Pizza in the U district.  VERY spicy sauce.  Yum!
Greg P.Demonotronics, Inc.Jun 1, 1998
 Also, the Fiddler's Inn on 94th and 35th NE.  Not really a pizza joint, but
 the pizza is really good anyway.
AnonymousJun 1, 1998
 >Thanks for the tip.  Is there anything else you can tell us about their
 >product?  Are the toppings fresh?  Plentiful?  What's the crust
 >like?  Do they use an appropriate amount of cheese?  Did it come
 >out of the oven at the right point in its baking cycle?

 Sorry, I didn't huddle back in the kitchen while they made the pizza.  All I
 can say is this.  It was a medium crust, more toward the thin end but not
 crunchy.  Lots of toppings.  Quality.  Enough cheese for a small amount of
 slice-to-mouth stretch, but not enough to give you that feeling of having
 eaten a lead weight.  It was very good, and we got two 16" combos for around
 $25 (including tip).
Share this page