Skip to main content
The Kitchen Archive

Eats Archive › Washington, DC

Washington, DC

O'Donnell's

1 post · Aug 17, 2001

John W.Aug 17, 2001
NNTP-Posting-Date: 17 Aug 2001 14:16:39 GMT
X-Mailer:  Mozilla 4.77 [en]C-STAR032398  (Win95; U) X-Accept-Language:  en Xref: usenet.INS.cwru.edu dc.dining:19990

I've never been to O'Donnell's until last night.  Your message made me suspect that they'd be closing and since this is a DC area institution, I wanted to check it out for historical sake.  Our waiter confirmed that they're closing October 4.  Condos will be put there.  I assume that includes the parking lot because surely just the restaurant property isn't worth $80M.  As far as good seafood restaurants, my favorite is Pesce on P near 20th west of  Dupont Circle.  Just a little closer to the Circle is Johnny's Half Shell also very good.  Pesce has the freshest possible fish.  Their menu is on a chauk board and changes at least daily.  Johnny's Half Shell's menu doesn't change often, and they also have non-seafood dishes.  Kinkead's is an outstanding restaurant, mostly seafood.  Legal Seafood downtown (2 locations), from Boston has well prepared seafood.  So does McCormack & Schmidt from Seattle downtown.  Good fresh seafood.  Their cheaper branch is M&S Grill.  They also have a restaurant in Bethesda.

Mary B. wrote:

> Just had dinner last night at O'Donnell's in Bethesda. The food was good, I
> had a combination shrimp, crab, and lobster sautee plate, however the shrimp
> were overcooked. The appetizers were very good: calamari, onion rings,
> steamed seasoned shrimp. Their wine list is quite nice we had an Italian
> 1999 Pinot Grigo for $24. The wine was sublime. Two points: they are selling
> the restaurant in September for $80 Million, I do not know if it will remain
> a restaurant. What a shame they have been in business since 1922. The one in
> Gaithersburg...I don't know about. Second point best friends are coming
> Labor Day week. I want to go to a great seafood restaurant in the metro
> area. Baltimore accepted too. I love The Dancing Crab in D.C. but it is too
> earthy for my group. I want nice atmosphere too..but the food is the most
> important. Thanks.
Share this page