Skip to main content
The Kitchen Archive

Eats Archive › Pennsylvania › Philadelphia

Philadelphia, PA

Seafood in Philly

10 posts · Jul 22, 1993 to Nov 30, 1994

AnonymousUniv of Penn - Med School Computer FacilityJul 22, 1993
>Does anyone know of any good seafood restaurants in Philly that is not too
>expensive for a college student?  Thanks in advance.

Sansom St Oyster House (15th and Sansom Sts.,
Phila. Fish and Co. (2nd and Chestnut Sts.)

      Karen Byrd, VAX Sys./Net. Manager
      University of Pennsylvania
      Medical School Computer Facility
      Philadelphia, PA 19104 (USA)
      Internet: [email removed]
Richard W.FTP Software, North Andover, MassachusettsNov 23, 1994
NNTP-Software: PC/TCP NNTP

Not sure if it is in your price range but ...
absolutely the best seafood i ever had was at Le Bec Fin last year.  Poached oysters with a sea urchin source served with steamed spinach and pastery. Absolutely unbelievable.  The rest of the meal was also exceptional.
Charles H.Drexel UniversityNov 23, 1994
In article , Tim Voltz
Someone wrote:

> Hi All--
>
> Does anyone have any good recommendations for a good place (or several
> good places) where I might find some good seafood in the City of
> Brotherly Love?  Doesn't have to be *IN* Philadelphia.  I will be SW of
> the city, so anywhere in the general area would be good.
>

Well, the place that is the old time Philly seafood restaurant is Old Original Bookbinders at Walnut between 2nd and Front streets.  But I find that this can be overwhelming and perhaps overpriced (although the portions are on the large side).

My favorite is Philadelphia Fish Company on Chestnut between 2nd and 3rd Streets - just a few blocks away.

************************************************************************** from the keyboard of:         Charles N. Haas:LD Betz Professor of Environmental Engineering Drexel University:::Philadelphia, PA 19104 [email removed]         OWNER: [email removed] [INSERT USUAL DISCLAIMER HERE]
**************************************************************************
Jack W.AT&T GISNov 23, 1994
>Someone wrote:
>Hi All--
>
>Does anyone have any good recommendations for a good place (or several
>good places) where I might find some good seafood in the City of
>Brotherly Love?  Doesn't have to be *IN* Philadelphia.  I will be SW of
>the city, so anywhere in the general area would be good.
>
>Thanks a lot.  You can email, or respond here.
>
>Tim Voltz
>Programmer/Analyst
>Cornell University Human Resource Services.
>[email removed]

Tim:

If you are anywhere near Philadelphia, The Original Bookbinders is a MUST!!.  I don't recall the address, but directions can be easily obtained from just about anyone.

I know there are many other excellent seafood restaurants in Philadelphia and it would also be worth your while to go about 17 miles slouth on I-95 to the Wilmington, New Castle, Delaware area.  This area is right on the Cheasapeake Bay and has great fresh seafood.

Jack Whitehead                     |  What? . . . Me worry? [email removed]    |  Alfred E. Neuman AT&T Global Information Solutions  |
Ann B.McCabe Library, Swarthmore CollegeNov 23, 1994
In article , Jack Whitehead
Someone wrote:

> >Someone wrote:
> >Hi All--
> >
> >Does anyone have any good recommendations for a good place (or several
> >good places) where I might find some good seafood in the City of
> >Brotherly Love?  Doesn't have to be *IN* Philadelphia.  I will be SW of
> >the city, so anywhere in the general area would be good.
> >
> >Thanks a lot.  You can email, or respond here.
> >
> >Tim Voltz
> >Programmer/Analyst
> >Cornell University Human Resource Services.
> >[email removed]
>
> Tim:
>
> If you are anywhere near Philadelphia, The Original Bookbinders is a MUST!!.  I
> don't
> recall the address, but directions can be easily obtained from just about
> anyone.
>
> I know there are many other excellent seafood restaurants in Philadelphia and it
> would also be worth your while to go about 17 miles slouth on I-95 to the
> Wilmington, New Castle, Delaware area.  This area is right on the Cheasapeake
> Bay and has great fresh seafood.
>
>
>
>
>
> Jack Whitehead                     |  What? . . . Me worry?
> [email removed]    |  Alfred E. Neuman
> AT&T Global Information Solutions  |

****************************

I think Bookbinders is highly overrated but quite like the Sansom Street Oyster House.  Unpretentious, not too expensive, good quality fish, oysters excellent.
AnonymousDrexel UniversityNov 23, 1994
>> >Does anyone have any good recommendations for a good place (or several
>> >good places) where I might find some good seafood in the City of
>> >Brotherly Love?  Doesn't have to be *IN* Philadelphia.  I will be SW od10
>> >the city, so anywhere in the general area would be good.
>> If you are anywhere near Philadelphia, The Original Bookbinders is a MUST!!.  I
I think Bookbinder's is just so-so and agree on The Sansom Street Oyster House.  I've haven't been there but The Striped Bass on Spruce St. is getting rave reviews and I hear it's always crowded (and expensive).   Michael's on 200 block of Chestnut St. isn't bad. For Crabs, Walt's on 2nd St and Dinardo's on Race St.  The original Dinardo's is in Wilmington and I hear it's even better but I haven't been there.  Walt's and Sansom Street have that local Philadelphia atmosphere.
DamUniversity of PennsylvaniaNov 23, 1994
DiNardo's gets my vote, and both locations are quite good, though the wait for a table is usually longer in Philly than it is in Wilmington, even though Wilmington is smaller...

Another favorite of our of late is the Chart House on Delaware Ave.  Yes, I know it's a national chain, but it's *excellent*.

------------------------------------------------------------------- Audrey Marsh                          "Set the gearshift for the [email removed]            high gear of your soul..." [email removed]                                - T. Marshall
-------------------------------------------------------------------
AnonymousDrexel UniversityNov 25, 1994
>[email removed]                                - T. Marshall
Another possibility is Le Ho Seafood Place at 941 Race St. in Chinatown. They sea creatures can be seen swimming around at the front of the restaurant.  Little Saigon at 1122 S. 8th St. near Italian Market is a Vietnamese retaurant with seafood a specialty.

>-------------------------------------------------------------------
Elliot R.J.P. Morgan & Co., Inc.Nov 29, 1994
Someone wrote:
> >> >Does anyone have any good recommendations for a good place (or several
> >> >good places) where I might find some good seafood in the City of
> >> >Brotherly Love?  Doesn't have to be *IN* Philadelphia.  I will be SW od10
> >> >the city, so anywhere in the general area would be good.
> >> If you are anywhere near Philadelphia, The Original Bookbinders is a MUST!!.  I

DiNardo's on Race St. gets my vote. If you can, go to the original in Wilmington. Walt's on 2nd St. has gone down hill. I would not recommend it any more. Service has become unbelievably bad and the food does not approach DiNardo's.
Julie P.University of PennsylvaniaNov 30, 1994
Someone wrote:
: >[email removed]                                - T. Marshall

Dmitri's at 3rd and Catherine in South Philly had GREAT grilled fist.  I love it.  Haven't tried it, but what about the new place for seafood in Philly, The Striped Bass?
-- Julie A Parr
Share this page