There's more than 1 Papa J's - If you're talking about the one on Washington Road in Mt. Lebanon, my husband and I go there all the time. We've never had a bad experience there. The food has always been good, and the service has been fine. The only thing is that everything is ala carte - so it can add up if you like salad with your pasta. Best value: the small antipasto salad is enormous - it can easily be shared by two as a substantial appetizer - or be eaten as a meal by one. Their white pizzas are very good, as are all of the pasta dishes I have tried.
Pittsburgh, PA