Skip to main content
The Kitchen Archive

Eats Archive › Pennsylvania › Pittsburgh

Pittsburgh, PA

BEST SEAFOOD?

3 posts · Jul 26, 1995 to Aug 4, 1995

Kim H.University of PittsburghJul 26, 1995
 Someone wrote:
 >
 > Whats the best seafood res. in Pittsburgh in your opinion?
 > I would have said Polis until recently....Prices went up and food went down!

 Well, I believe that the Rodi Road Grille has probably the best
 in the city.  I was there a couple of months ago, and was quite pleased
 with the Walleye I got there.  The service was also excellent as well.

 The one place that I implore you *not* to go, under any circumstances,
 is Buster's Crab down on the Boardwalk in the Strip.  I have never
 seen a worse excuse for a seafood restaurant in my entire life!  Two
 people at our table ordered crab legs, and they were completely
 frozen (and obviously ice cold) when they were brought to our table.
 My trout also looked like it was microwaved for about an hour, and was
 hastily covered with some sort of seasoning that didn't even remotely
 resemble what I had ordered (I ordered blackened trout).  Another
 person at our table ordered the lobster tail, and his lobster was
 undercooked.  Our service was horrible to top it; it took forever for
 the waiter to come over and take our orders, it took forever for him
 to bring us our drinks, the waiter never came and asked us how
 everything was, and he didn't seem at all concerned with the fact
 that the crab legs were frozen in the middle and wanted them taken
 off our bill rather than risk another bad order. I could understand
 slow service if the restaurant was packed and understaffed, but there
 seemed to be plenty of help around the restaurant, and the restaurant
 was only about half full.

 Sorry to sound so negative, but I really don't want you to waste a
 bunch of money for a completely unsatisfying dining experience.
 Stick to Rodi Road Grille.

 ++Kim
BERLINBEARAmerica Online, Inc. (1-800-827-6364)Jul 27, 1995
 My brother (the butcher and meat buyer at the Duquesne Club) recommends
 Jake's Above the Square for seafood.  It's pricey, though.

 Dave Devine
Bob P.Heinz School, Carnegie Mellon, Pittsburgh, PAAug 4, 1995
 I have enjoyed the daily fish selections at Tassaro's (Bloomfield) on
 three or four occasions.  Prepared simply over a mesquite grill to your
 specifications, I've found their selections to be reasonably priced,
 fresh, and flavorful.  (I also enjoy the ambience of a crowded small
 bar/restaurant with friendly waiters and host.)

 Bob Pearson
 [email removed]
Share this page