Skip to main content
The Kitchen Archive

Eats Archive › Pennsylvania › Pittsburgh

Pittsburgh, PA

Best Fish Sandwich in PGH. and Western PA area

5 posts · Jul 16, 1998 to Aug 8, 1998

Michal S.University of PittsburghJul 16, 1998
 Add to that:

 Union Grill on Craig St.

 Philip K. wrote:
 >
 > I agree......Jimmys has a wonderful fish sandwich. But is it the best? Lets
 > just say it ranks with the best.
 > Other honorable mentions:
 >
 > Armands  Liberty Ave in Lawrenceville
 > Chiefs in Oakland
 > Renees in East McKeesport (my personal favorite)
 >
Timothy F.ICGNetcomJul 16, 1998
 As I said during Lent when this question was rasied one of the best
 around is at McNeilly RD Foodland it is off of Route88 in the South
 Hills.They are made only on Fridays but for $3.50 you can't beat it 100%
 COD
Christine B.Univ. of PittsburghJul 17, 1998
 In article , Timothy Friez
 Someone wrote:

 > As I said during Lent when this question was rasied one of the best
 > around is at McNeilly RD Foodland it is off of Route88 in the South
 > Hills.They are made only on Fridays but for $3.50 you can't beat it 100%
 > COD

 If you're in that area, try the Oaks Lounge on Sleepy Hollow Rd,
 next to the Giant Eagle. But...
 the BEST fish sandwich is on Rt 88 closer to South Park at
 Pasta Too - massive, on a great bun that's prctically a loaf of bread.

 Christine

 Christine Berliner
 [email removed]
L. G.University of PittsburghJul 20, 1998
 Try Keith's in Trafford.  Alot of fish for cheap and his homemade hot
 sauce is excellent.
Jason B.MindSpring EnterprisesAug 8, 1998
 You might also want to try out Rocky's.  It's in Heidelberg on Route
 50.  Butya's is also good, but I like Rocky's a bit better.  If you
 can believe it, Rocky's is even bigger!!  They have a good selection
 of other food as well - big dinner entrees and great chili too.
 Believe the fish sandwich is around $4.75 if I remember correctly.
 Doesn't come on a hoagie bun, just a big keiser round bun.  I'd ask
 for a 2nd bun, as you'll be lucky to fit even half of it on the bun
 they give you :)

 On Sat, 25 Jul 1998 20:00:49 -0700, "Richard M. Hays, Jr."
 Someone wrote:

 >John A. wrote:
 >>
 >> On 17 Jul 1998 15:05:55 GMT, [email removed] (Christine
 >> Berliner) wrote:
 >>
 >> >the BEST fish sandwich is on Rt 88 closer to South Park at
 >> >Pasta Too - massive, on a great bun that's prctically a loaf of bread.
 >>
 >> Nah - y'all missed it. THE best fish sandwich in the area is at
 >> Butya's in Robinson Township on Rt 60. Don't go on Fridays for lunch
 >> OR dinner unless you are prepared to wait. It's about $5 or $6, but
 >> the bun does not exist that can hold it!!
 >>
 >> John
 >Thanks, John for another great recommendation. I understand that place
 >also had great musical entertainment at one time. Is that still true?
 >
 >Richard M. Hays, Jr.
 >E-mail: [email removed]
 >Whiskey Rebellion Toastmasters Web site:--http://trfn.clpgh.org/speak/
Share this page