Skip to main content
The Kitchen Archive

Eats Archive › New York › Rochester

Rochester, NY

Good Food in Western NY

3 posts · Apr 11, 1997 to Apr 30, 1997

Tom J.Tiger TransportsApr 11, 1997
If anyone is ever in Rochester,NY and is looking for a place to eat, try Nick's. His restaurant is famous around here for it's "garbage plate". It is a choice of meat(hots,hamburgs,etc.) atop a MOUNTAIN of food(choice of 2 of the following:beans,french fries,macaroni salad or home fries.) It's all topped off with mustard,onions and Nick's secret hot sauce. Nobody knows what the sauce is and nobody has been able to copy it, but it sure does taste good! This all looks pretty disgusting on the plate(hence the name) but it is oh-so-good! Nick Tahou's is 1 exit north of I-490 on I-390 which is Rt.31 Lyell Ave. Go west on Lyell Ave a couple hundred feet, and Nick's is on the right before the traffic light....Enjoy!!!
Joel C.Frontier Internet Rochester N.Y. (716)-777-SURFApr 24, 1997
Tom J. wrote:

>If anyone is ever in Rochester,NY and is looking for a place to eat, try
>Nick's. His restaurant is famous around here for it's "garbage plate". It is
>a choice of meat(hots,hamburgs,etc.) atop a MOUNTAIN of food(choice of 2 of
>the following:beans,french fries,macaroni salad or home fries.) It's all
>topped off with mustard,onions and Nick's secret hot sauce. Nobody knows what
>the sauce is and nobody has been able to copy it, but it sure does taste good!
>This all looks pretty disgusting on the plate(hence the name) but it is
>oh-so-good! Nick Tahou's is 1 exit north of I-490 on I-390 which is Rt.31
>Lyell Ave. Go west on Lyell Ave a couple hundred feet, and Nick's is on the
>right before the traffic light....Enjoy!!!

If you're going to lead people to Nick's, you should give them the full experience and give them directions to the original one on Main St. (near Broad St.)

Also, for the full experience, you should go to either after midnight. :-)
Dan W.Frontier Internet Rochester N.Y. (716)-777-SURFApr 30, 1997
Tom J. wrote:
>If anyone is ever in Rochester,NY and is looking for a place to eat, try
>Nick's. His restaurant is famous around here for it's "garbage plate". It is
>a choice of meat(hots,hamburgs,etc.) atop a MOUNTAIN of food(choice of 2 of
>the following:beans,french fries,macaroni salad or home fries.) It's all
>topped off with mustard,onions and Nick's secret hot sauce. Nobody knows what
>the sauce is and nobody has been able to copy it, but it sure does taste good!
>This all looks pretty disgusting on the plate(hence the name) but it is
>oh-so-good! Nick Tahou's is 1 exit north of I-490 on I-390 which is Rt.31
>Lyell Ave. Go west on Lyell Ave a couple hundred feet, and Nick's is on the
>right before the traffic light....Enjoy!!!

The original Nick Tahou's is on West Main, in an old railroad station.  Nick passed away a couple of months ago.

          _
         (_)   Daniel Warren, RPh
  _______//    Marion NY
 (________)    Clinical Staff Pharmacist - Strong Memorial Hospital
  \      /     [email removed]
   | Rx |
  /______\
 (________)
Share this page