Skip to main content
The Kitchen Archive

Eats Archive › Massachusetts › Boston

Boston, MA

Boston Seafood: Help?

10 posts · Dec 4, 1994 to Dec 9, 1994

Rob G.Boston CollegeDec 4, 1994
 Cross-posted to ne.food for obvious reasons; since the original
 poster might not see that group, probably follow-ups should go to
 both groups...

 Michael F. wrote:

 >1) Which is the best of the "Legal Seafood" branches?  I recall
 >favourably one situated in a basement, and not so favourably a
 >mainfloor branch further west.

 I have had good meals at the one in the Park Plaza and in Kendall
 Square, Cambridge (near MIT).  I have had variable experiences at
 the Legal in the Chestnut Hill Mall, in Brookline/Newton.  I
 think that the restaurants all get their fish from a common
 source, and I experienced variations in service more than in
 quality of food.

 >2) Which is downtown Boston's best seafood restaurant?

 I might be going out on a limb here, but my favorite remains
 Durgin-Park.  I would avoid the Union Oyster House at all costs.

 If "downtown" includes the waterfront, then you might also check
 out the No-Name.  According to some articles in the Globe from a
 year or two ago, Anthony's Pier Four (also on the waterfront) has
 gone downhill, and sounds as if it should be avoided.

 If you will accept seafood with an Italian flair, then your
 possible choices expand greatly.  I have had excellent fish at
 Dom's and Pomodoro's in the North End, but that's not to slight
 many other North End restaurants that serve wonderful shrimp or
 lobster dishes.

 If downtown includes Chinatown, you might check out "Chau
 Chow's", where a live fish will be scooped from a tank and
 brought to the table for your approval before cooking.

 Happy eating.--Rob
AnonymousStratus Computer, Marlboro Ma.Dec 4, 1994
 Rob G. wrote:
 >If downtown includes Chinatown, you might check out "Chau
 >Chow's", where a live fish will be scooped from a tank and
 >brought to the table for your approval before cooking.
 >

 thats  GRAND CHAU CHAU that has the tanks (its across teh street
 from CHAU CHAU though).

 in  addition  you  may wanna try EASTERN PIER SEAFOOD RESTAURANT
 (by same owner of both Chau Chau's).  There is fish in the  tank
 too.
JEFFREY B.NetcomDec 5, 1994
 While not strictly seafood, Jaspers in the North End is one of the best
 restaurants and knows how to do fish.  The No Name is No Game and should
 be avoided.

 Rob G. wrote:

 >
 >Cross-posted to ne.food for obvious reasons; since the original
 >poster might not see that group, probably follow-ups should go to
 >both groups...
 >
 >Michael F. wrote:
 >
 >>1) Which is the best of the "Legal Seafood" branches?  I recall
 >>favourably one situated in a basement, and not so favourably a
 >>mainfloor branch further west.
 >
 >I have had good meals at the one in the Park Plaza and in Kendall
 >Square, Cambridge (near MIT).  I have had variable experiences at
 >the Legal in the Chestnut Hill Mall, in Brookline/Newton.  I
 >think that the restaurants all get their fish from a common
 >source, and I experienced variations in service more than in
 >quality of food.
 >
 >>2) Which is downtown Boston's best seafood restaurant?
 >
 >I might be going out on a limb here, but my favorite remains
 >Durgin-Park.  I would avoid the Union Oyster House at all costs.
 >
 >If "downtown" includes the waterfront, then you might also check
 >out the No-Name.  According to some articles in the Globe from a
 >year or two ago, Anthony's Pier Four (also on the waterfront) has
 >gone downhill, and sounds as if it should be avoided.
 >
 >If you will accept seafood with an Italian flair, then your
 >possible choices expand greatly.  I have had excellent fish at
 >Dom's and Pomodoro's in the North End, but that's not to slight
 >many other North End restaurants that serve wonderful shrimp or
 >lobster dishes.
 >
 >If downtown includes Chinatown, you might check out "Chau
 >Chow's", where a live fish will be scooped from a tank and
 >brought to the table for your approval before cooking.
 >
 >Happy eating.--Rob
 >
 >--
 >Rob Gross                              (617) 552-3758 / 232-1838
 >Department of Mathematics              BITNET:   [email removed]
 >Boston College                         Internet: [email removed]
 >Chestnut Hill, MA 02167-3806                     [email removed]
 >
Betsy S.North Shore Access/Eco Software, Inc; ()Dec 5, 1994
 Our favorite local Chinese restaurant, Chang Feng's on Beacon St in
 Somerville (next to the Star Market, across from Jimmy Mac's) has recently
 updated their menu and and added more "Shanghai style" dishes.  These
 include the sorts of odds-and-ends of seafood and pork (sea urchin?  Pig
 ears?) that you otherwise have to go to Chinatown for. Unlike the Chinatown
 restaurants, Chang Feng uses no MSG. Great spinach. Wonderful hot spicy
 garlic noodles. Big bowls of noodle soup.

 I've gotten SO sick every time I've eaten at the Chau Chau; the food tastes
 WONDERFUL but they don't understand about "no MSG." I've never had an
 MSG-free meal in Chinatown. If MSG doesn't bother you, Chau Chau is great.
M. P.The KMPeterson GroupDec 5, 1994
 in article
 Michael F. wrote:

 >1) Which is the best of the "Legal Seafood" branches?  I recall
 >favourably one situated in a basement, and not so favourably a
 >mainfloor branch further west.

 I've had good meals at all of the locations.  I think that the variables are
 service and waiting times.  The branch in the Park Plaza can get _extremely_
 busy, whereas I've had very good luck in Kendall Square.  (I think you could
 consider the Park Plaza (at Park Square) branch in the basement).

 >2) Which is downtown Boston's best seafood restaurant?

 I think that you could call Park Square (not to be confused with Park Street)
 downtown, and I'd say that Legal is among the best.  Turner Fisheries, at the
 Westin Hotel in Copley place is also similarly ranked.

 Perhaps my favorite is in the North End: Giacomo's on Hanover Street.  Another
 drag to get into on a weekend night, but generally very worthwhile.  There's a
 new location of theirs in the South End (10' walk from Legal/Park Plaza), but
 I'm not sure whether they've kept the quality up.

 Also, finally, I had dinner at the East Coast Grill in Inman Square in
 Cambridge several months ago with a good friend, a native Californian.  She
 claimed that the tuna steak she had was the best she'd ever tasted in her
 life.  (But of course again problematic getting in).

 Have fun!

 _KMP
 [email removed] http://www.tiac.net/users/peterson/home.html
AnonymousKittenz 'R' UsDec 5, 1994
 Personally I'll be going back for the cajun haddock at Legals in Kendall
 Square.

 Oh!  and Jimbos makes a great fish stew.
James T.Thinking Machines Corporation, Cambridge MA, USADec 8, 1994Subject: Re: Boston Seafood: Where's the Best Indian Pudding?
 Robin L. wrote:

    While Durgin's Indian Pudding is good, the BEST used to be at the restaurant
    in the old Statler Hotel at Park Square (we're going back a few decades here!).
    What's the best Indian Pudding in Boston now?

    Rob Lake
    [email removed]

 Locke Ober's indian pudding is very good.  Somewhat "more subtle" than
 Durgin Park's [i.e., a less strong molasses flavor].

 jim
G. E.ISUDec 8, 1994
 Dolphin Seafood on Mass Ave in Cambridge - good food, great prices.
 Crowded, especially at lunch.  No ambiance.
Andrew B.Massachusetts Institute of TechnologyDec 8, 1994
 I would take the atmosphere and spices of the seafood at
 the Green Street Grill (near Central sq) over the
 good but dull dining at Legal any day.

 andrew bernard
Mark S.The World Public Access UNIX, Brookline, MADec 9, 1994
 Someone wrote:
 : Twice "spicy" has been mentioned... I love spicy food, and I'm going
 : home to Boston for Christmas.

 : Can you list some of the menu items?  Thanks!

 [ menu items for Green Street Grill (aka Charlie's Tap) in Cambridge ]

 The Green Street menu changes often, but generally consists of spicy
 Carribean cuisine; much of it seafood.  Often times you will see menu
 items prepared with serrano or habenero chiles - very intense stuff.

 Entrees I have tried:  tuna steak, salmon, wild boar, venison, pork ribs,
 marlin, rabbit (I think...) and the "Green Street Pepper Pot", a spicy
 stew of various clams, mussels, shrimp, and squid.  All good stuff.

 Great appetizers, too: mussels steamed in Bass Ale; Beaten, Boiled and
 Abused Conch Meat are two excellent choices, best shared by two or three
 people.

 A visit back in September or October was rather disappointing; my brother
 and I both received unacceptably small portions of fish.  We were ready
 to give up on the place.  Things were back to normal when we returned in
 November.

 Also, if it's busy and you wait at the bar for a table, make sure you wait
 as close to the dining room entrance as possible.  The owner and maitre'd
 is unfogivably flaky in his handling of customers, and he'll forget about
 you if you sit too far away from him.  This has happened to us many times.

 |+|  M a r k  |+|
Share this page